The firm’s issued (what feels like) another profit warning. But the core of my thesis is still intact.

What’s been going wrong?

In general, UK housebuilders have been in a tough situation. Demand has been weak and conflict in the Middle East has been pushing up costs. This has been a problem across the industry.

But Vistry’s found itself in a weaker position than most of its major competitors. Unlike other builders, the firm began the year with a net debt position. And that’s significantly reduced its flexibility in a tough market.

Having obligations to meet means the company’s had to offer bigger discounts to get houses sold. But that’s set to result in lower profits. That’s where the latest profit warning’s come from.

But the things that make Vistry different could be a long-term advantage. 

Short interest

Vistry’s been one of the UK’s most heavily-shorted stocks. And with the stock down 60% this year, it’s fair to say that’s worked well.

Does that mean I was wrong to buy the stock? My timing was certainly off, but I’m not giving up on this one with over half the year left.

In its latest update, Vistry outlined a number of moves to get back on track. These include further discounts and limiting land purchases.

Importantly however, management said the following:

The combined effect of the above actions is expected to deliver significantly lower average net debt levels in the second half and we are now expecting a net cash position in excess of £100m at 31 December 2026.

If it can get to this position, I think the stock looks incredibly cheap. It has a market value of £810m and there’s a big opportunity on the way.

The opportunity

So far, Vistry looks like an ordinary housebuilder with an unusually bad balance sheet. But there’s a potentially huge opportunity ahead. 

The government’s Social and Affordable Homes Programme (SAHP) is underway. And there are two reasons why this could be huge for the firm. The first is that Vistry’s one of only two companies with Strategic Partner Plus status. This means it can bid directly for £700m in funding. 

The other is that it has relationships with the local authorities and housing associations that can bid for the rest. And that’s unusual. Vistry has been turning itself into a specialist in this area. So the £39bn SAHP programme should be a huge opportunity.

Make or break time

Vistry’s issues aren’t imaginary. But my investment thesis for the stock remains intact, for the time being. 

I still think there’s a massive opportunity ahead. And the falling share price actually reinforces this.

There’s a lot hanging on the SAHP programme. Vistry’s open market business is facing some serious challenges. If the firm can fix its balance sheet, the second half of 2026 could be much more positive than the first. So I’m cautiously optimistic.

As the stock continues to fall, I’m steadily adding to my position. We’ll see soon enough whether or not that’s the right move.

Should you invest £5,000 in Vistry Group Plc right now?

When investing expert Mark Rogers and his team have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Twelfth Magpie Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets.

And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if Vistry Group Plc made the list?

Stephen Wright has positions in Vistry.

The post Should I use £1,000 to buy 392 shares in one of the most heavily-discounted UK stocks of 2026? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

Like those of other housebuilding stocks, the Iran War has pushed Vistry’s share price sharply lower. Valuations have dropped as the conflict drives up inflation and slows homebuyer acvitity. But has the stock market overreacted?

Not if Vistry’s trading update is anything to go by…

So what’s Vistry said?

Markets hate uncertainty. So investors have reacted badly to Vistry’s advice that in the last two months

the level of macro-economic uncertainty has increased, and with it the range of potential outcomes for the current year.

What it did predict is that it expects H1 profit “to be significantly lower than the prior year.” In better news, performance in H2 is tipped to match that of the same period in 2025, thanks to better margins on active sites and rising demand from the firm’s affordable housing partners.

The company now expects adjusted pre-tax profit for the full year to come in around the middle of the range of analysts’ forecasts. These currently sit at £168m to £283m. Profits were £268.8m in 2025.

What about sales rates?

Vistry said its open market sales rate is up 32% since 1 January (at 1.2 versus 0.91 last year). However, it’s also seen “some moderation in recent weeks reflecting uncertainty arising from the Middle East conflict,” it noted, prompting it to introduce more incentives and discounts for buyers, particularly on low-margin sites.

Vistry’s forward order book is £4.5bn, down from £4.6bn at the same point in 2025.

It’s not just sales rates that are under pressure as buyer caution and mortgage products becoming more expensive. Building material and labour costs are also rising, which Vistry has noted recently and expects to continue into H2.

It’s no surprise that the shares have plummeted again. The company now trades on a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 7.3 times. But I’m wondering: could now be an attractive dip-buying opportunity?

A FTSE 250 bargain?

I’m not expecting things to get better any time soon. Things could in fact get much worse. Yet I’m optimistic Vistry’s share price will recover strongly over time. And for long-term investors, now might be a good time to consider opening a position.

It’s also important to think about how cheap the share now is. That P/E of 7.3 is miles below the 10-year average of 14–15. What’s more, Vistry’s price-to-book (P/B) value of 0.3 shows the company trading at a massive discount to its balance sheet assets.

It makes me believe that — for patient investors at least — it might be one of the best value shares to consider right now. Long term, the outlook for the housing market remains robust, driven by the UK’s booming population. And the company has a new chief executive, Adam Daniels, to help it seize this opportunity. Just remember there could be some more bumps along the way.

The post Down 55%! Is this one of the FTSE 250’s greatest value shares? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

That’s exactly where Vistry Group (LSE: VTY) finds itself today, with the share price down around 73% over the past five years.

For anyone holding the stock, the question is simple: should you cut your losses, or hang on in hope of a recovery?

What the numbers actually say

Despite the drop, Vistry still looks like an efficient business rather than a basket case. 

Sure, the shares slipped a further 2% this past week, but it remains profitable, with a net margin of 3.8% and a healthy 8.5% operating margin. Earnings per share (EPS) grew roughly 6% since this time last year, and the group is still generating around £270m in adjusted profit before tax.

But the real story here is net income growth. Up from just £31m in H1 2025 to £106.7m in H2, it seems to have already initiated a recovery. On top of that, it boasts a very attractive valuation. The shares are trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of just 8, with a price‑to‑book (P/B) ratio of only 0.31.

When adding in earnings growth, we get a super-low P/E to growth (PEG) ratio of just 0.08. That’s the second lowest (after Serco Group) of profitable non-fund stocks on the FTSE 250.

So what’s the catch?

The balance sheet’s still in recovery mode, but it’s not stretched to breaking point. Long-term assets comfortably cover long‑term liabilities and it’s begun an aggressive push to preserve cash.

However, there are real red flags. After pausing dividends in 2023, the board made it clear that further payouts will depend on stronger cash flow and lower debt.

It also faces a tough housing backdrop, with interest‑rate‑sensitive buyers, competition for lower‑margin homes and a historically weak share‑price track record.

Are there better options to consider?

If you like the UK housing story but want a bit more stability, there are alternatives worth looking at. Berkeley Group, Bellway and Legal & General all operate in the housebuilding or property‑linked space and have more consistent dividend histories. They’re not immune to market swings but they seem more stable.

For income investors, a property-focused investment trust or more diversified housebuilder may feel preferable to a single‑name stock that has halved twice in a decade.

So should I Sell or Hold?

The reality of the situation can’t be ignored: Vistry’s cheap because it has disappointed investors many times before. Yes, the numbers indicate some improvements, with margins edging up and cash flow stabilising. But the stock price still reflects deep scepticism.

For those comfortable with high volatility, a possible multi‑year recovery and the risk of no dividend for a while, it could be worth holding. But even then, only as a small, speculative portion of a portfolio.

From my side, I’m thinking of cutting my losses and looking for a more diversified UK property-focused trust. In the long run, it may be a less stressful way to back the housing market than betting on a single housebuilder that’s already lost three‑quarters of its value in five years.

The post Down 73%, Vistry’s the worst-performing FTSE 250 share in my portfolio. Time to sell? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

One of the worst-affected has been Vistry (LSE:VTY), which is down 47.59% in the last 12 months. But the firm might have a huge opportunity ahead.

Company overview

Unlike other UK builders, Vistry builds houses for institutional partners. These include housing associations, local authorities, and the private rental sector.

In theory, there are two big advantages to this. The first is that it doesn’t have to finance the build itself, which makes it more capital efficient.

The second is that a lot of its houses are sold before they’re built. This reduces the firm’s exposure to the ups and downs of the housing market. 

On the other side of the coin, there are drawbacks. Selling to partners typically means lower margins – that’s the trade-off for financing and certainty. 

There’s also a risk of complexity. External partners rely on funding and delays to this can create working capital challenges for Vistry. 

The partnership model has pros and cons. But right now, it means the company could be looking at a huge opportunity. 

SAHP

The UK government is committed to building around 300,000 new homes a year. A big part of this is the Social and Affordable Homes Programme (SAHP). 

This offers £39bn in funding for new homes that meet certain affordability criteria. And it’s a big deal for Vistry in two ways. 

First, the company is one of two organisations that has Strategic Partner Plus status. That means it can bid directly for up to £700m in funding. 

Second, the main bidders are likely to be housing associations and local authorities. But these are exactly the organisations Vistry already partners with.

These existing relationships give the company a huge advantage over competitors. And this hasn’t gone unnoticed by its competitors. 

In the context of a firm with a £1.25bn enterprise value, the opportunity could be huge. The stock market, however, appears to be focused on other issues.

Why is the stock down?

Housebuilders have been offering discounts to shift inventory in a weak market. And that includes Vistry as it winds down its open market division.

This is never a good thing. But it’s more of a problem for the company than some of its rivals. 

Vistry carries more debt than most housebuilders. That’s a feature of its partner-focused model, which means it needs less cash to operate.

It means, however, that the firm can find itself needing to raise cash more urgently. And that’s why it’s been discounting more aggressively.

The stock market – rightly – isn’t impressed with this. But I think the company is at a major turning point. 

Vistry plans to focus on SAHP projects from H2 onwards. And when it does, I expect things to change dramatically.

Hard to resist

At £3.36, I think the share price is hard to resist. I own the stock in my ISA, but another £1,000 for 297 shares won’t ruin my diversification.

It’s one I’m looking very carefully at right now. And I’m expecting to add to my investment before the second half of the year.

The post £1,000 buys 297 shares in this beaten-down UK housebuilder with a £700m opportunity appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

It’s hard to get my head around a company in an in-demand sector such as housebuilding falling so far and so quickly.

I’m always on the lookout for a bargain, which is why 80% off Vistry shares have caught my attention today. Is this the kind of chance to buy into a stock that only comes around once every 10 years or more? Or is there more than meets the eye here?

What’s the problem?

On the surface, you might wonder what the problem was. The country’s crying out for new houses to be built. And the government is trying to get construction back to the levels of the 1950s with plenty of housing reforms on the agenda. What’s more, this has been reflected in the revenue figures with Vistry keeping above £3.5bn for each of the last three financial years (it was £2.4bn in 2021).

So what’s the problem? The main issue is inflation which is squeezing margins. Costs are going up – supply costs have been rising since the Ukraine conflict. The government’s added on a bunch of wage costs too. Housebuilders across the country are dealing with making less money off each completion.

Vistry’s suffering perhaps more than any other too. The firm’s pivot to affordable housing and working with local authorities seemed a good idea a few years ago. The reality is that the company has had to use the public market and incentives like paying customers’ stamp duty to keep the sales coming in. Not an ideal situation.

A string of profit warnings has accompanied the slide in share price. A staggering 20% drop in a single day ignominiously hurt earlier this year. The dividend has stopped being paid too.

Poor shape

Vistry looks in poor shape compared to other housebuilders. For example, Taylor Wimpey shares have been struggling too, but that housebuilder has a stronger asset base, lower debt and is still paying a 9% dividend to boot.

Perhaps the brightest spot is that most of the pain might now be in the rear-view mirror. Earnings and revenues are forecast to rise in the years ahead – albeit slowly. Analyst recommendations look optimistic and the dividend could be set to return. A price-to-earnings ratio of just eight looks cheap too.

There’s a lot of risk to investing here. Many a stock that looks cheap after a big dip just goes on to keep dropping – the classic falling knife. For an investor aware of the high-risk profile, it could be worth considering however.

The post Is now a once-in-a-decade opportunity to buy Vistry shares? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

There are however, big discounts still on offer. So I don’t think investors should be put off by a rising stock market.

Vistry

I was thinking of buying shares in FTSE 250 housebuilder Vistry (LSE:VTY). But the stock surged 15% on Wednesday (8 April) which is annoying. 

A rising price though, doesn’t automatically mean a stock’s expensive. And I think this is a good illustration of that point. 

The main challenge facing the firm though, is still there. It’s the fact that affordability issues mean its existing inventory isn’t shifting. Like most other builders, the company’s selling these at lower prices. But that isn’t a good thing for margins in the short term.

Fortunately, Vistry’s in a unique position. It operates through partnerships with housing associations, local authorities, and rental agencies. I think these connections are set to be a huge advantage. The UK has just launched a £39bn plan for affordable housing that lasts 10 years.

Vistry’s existing relationships mean a lot of this could come the company’s way. And the current market value is £1.1bn. In my view, that’s still a very attractive equation. So despite the rising share price, I’m still interested in buying. 

Judges Scientific

Unlike a lot of UK shares, Judges Scientific (LSE:JDG) didn’t really move on Wednesday. As a result, the stock still looks cheap to me. 

The scientific instrument firm’s earnings per share are set to fall in 2026, which isn’t a good sign. But it’s worth looking more closely at why. 

One reason is to do with Geotek – its coring subsidiary. Contracts in this business are infrequent and there isn’t one expected in 2026.  Management however, expects roughly three every four years going forward. So that means this year’s earnings will be unusually low. 

Another reason is the situation in the US. The administration’s attempts to research funding had been weighing on demand for scientific instruments. This however, has been shot down by Congress. In fact, it’s been replaced with increases to the National Institutes for Health’s budget. 

Judges Scientific isn’t seeing increased demand yet, but I think it’s coming. And if I’m right, the stock’s a lot cheaper than it looks. I expect 2026 to be a bad year on paper for the business. But I’m expecting a strong rebound thereafter, which is why I think the stock looks cheap.

Time to buy?

The stock market has just had a big boost from easing geopolitical tensions. So investors might think it’s not the time to be buying. My view though, is that this is a mistake. There are still UK stock that look attractive to me, even with prices generally heading higher. 

At times like this, there are two things to remember: higher prices don’t automatically mean stocks are overvalued; and not every stock is the same. A rising market doesn’t mean that everything’s more expensive.

Investors who keep these two points in mind are in a good position to look for potential opportunities. And that’s what I’m doing right now.

The post With share prices rising, is now the time to hold off buying stocks? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

While such a large fall could be a warning sign, the obvious question here is whether this is a golden opportunity to buy in at a low point? Are Vistry shares a dirt-cheap bargain?

Changes

An important first consideration is the rest of the housing sector. If we compare to the high that Vistry fell 76% from, we see that other stocks have suffered too. Other UK housebuilders like Persimmon (down 35%), Taylor Wimpey (down 45%), and Barratt Redrow (down 53%) have not escaped the carnage.

The major problem is that margins are getting squeezed all over. Supply cost inflation has been rising, wages have been bumped up, and mortgages are more expensive with interest rates set to rise. We would likely need to see some change for this notoriously cyclical sector to turn around here.

Vistry being the worst of the lot is likely down to the nature of its operations. As well as building and selling houses to the public, its completions are often arranged with partnerships – local authorities or housing associations and such. This can mean stability when times are good, but recently it has led to lower margins and alarming profit warnings.

To cap things off, long-time CEO Greg Fitzgerald announcing his departure has not helped matters either.

Key point

So what are the reasons for optimism here? The stand-out statistic is surely the valuation, a price-to-earnings ratio of just eight is one of the lowest across the entire London Stock Exchange. That means we’re getting a lot of earnings for the cost of every share – a sign the share price might be at a low point.

As mentioned, housing tends to be cyclical in nature. The boom years of the early 2010s saw many housebuilders go on a complete tear. The share price of Vistry – known as Bovis Homes then – tripled in less than five years without even taking into account dividends. The key point, perhaps, is that investors would have had to buy in after the 2008 crash.

Buying a strong share at a low point will always prove to be a winning strategy in the stock market. It’s not obvious that Vistry will be one of those rare once-in-a-decade buying opportunities today, but it very well could be. I think investors could give it consideration.

The post Are 76% off Vistry shares a once-in-a-decade opportunity? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

The weight of problems

The primary factor came earlier in March when Vistry warned that profit margins would fall this year because it’s offering incentives to boost sales and generate cash. It noted that buyers are struggling with affordability, so with the need to keep sales going, it’ll look to offer financing support and other measures. Naturally, lower profit margins will likely mean lower profits, causing the stock to fall.

Another factor was that the full-year results weren’t amazing. Revenue was down by 4%, with the CEO noting “near-term market conditions remain challenging and current international events introduce new uncertainty”. Talking about the CEO, Greg Fitzgerald, raises another point of recent concern for investors. At the start of March, it was revealed that he will retire from the top job after nearly nine years. He will remain as CEO for up to a year to facilitate a transition, but it adds another layer of uncertainty to operations for the year ahead.

Finally, the business is under pressure from a less direct angle. The conflict in the Middle East is driving energy prices higher. If sustained, this will feed through to higher UK inflation. This has already caused investors to adjust their forecasts for where interest rates go this year. Instead of anticipating multiple cuts, we could see the base rate stay on hold, or even increase. This is negative for Vistry, as higher interest rates also raise mortgage costs, further dampening consumer demand.

The direction from here

The sharp fall has pushed the stock to the lowest level in over a decade. Some may think this is a good time to buy, believing the stock to be undervalued. The price-to-earnings ratio has dropped sharply, and is now at 6.88. I use 10 as a fair-value ratio, so it’s clearly below that.

If we take a step back, it’s true that the UK still has a chronic housing shortage, especially affordable housing. Data shows that Vistry builds one in seven affordable homes in the UK. So long-term demand should be strong for the business if it can weather the short-term storm.

However, it’s a high-risk opportunity. The push to quickly sell properties has me worried about short-term liquidity pressures internally. If this is the case, it could be forced to take on higher debt to keep operating. This could lead to higher costs and weigh down the company further.

Even though I think the stock has suffered an excessive fall, I’m going to wait for a few weeks to see where the price settles before thinking about buying. It’s been a one-way ticket lower for the past few weeks, and there’s nothing right now that suggests it’s slowing down.

The post Down 43% in a month, what on earth’s going on with the Vistry share price? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

But sometimes a beaten-down stock can be a bit of a bargain. Could this be the case here? Let’s discuss.

What’s going on?

Vistry Group (LSE:VTY) was punished by investors last Wednesday (4 March). Its share price fell 25.6% following the publication of its 2025 results. The housebuilder’s shares were last trading at this level in November 2012. Nearly 14 years of going nowhere is hugely disappointing.

Last week’s events are even more depressing given that shareholders probably thought the worst was behind the group.

In October 2024, Vistry issued a profit warning after it discovered it had got some of its cost estimates wrong. Embarrassingly, just four weeks later, it had to announce the situation was worse than the group had initially thought. A third warning followed in December 2024, following a deterioration in trading conditions.

But a closer look at the group’s 2025 results suggests investors may have over-reacted last week. At 59.3p, adjusted earnings per share was 6% higher than in 2024. The stock now trades at an attractive 7.8 times historic earnings.

However, the group did warn that it was employing “targeted pricing and sales incentives”, which would lead to a “lower overall margin” this year. Even so, it expects to end 2026 in a net cash position.

What I suspect upset the City the most was the decision to suspend its share buyback programme. The group stopped its dividend in 2023, diverting the money saved to buying its own shares. This policy has now been scrapped with the group planning to use its surplus cash to reduce its debt.

A different business model

The group’s unusual in that its main focus is affordable housing, commonly defined as “housing for sale or rent for those whose needs are not met by the market”. In 2025, it built one in seven of these types of properties in the country. It should therefore benefit from the government’s £39bn Social and Affordable Homes Programme (SAHP), which is to run for 10 years until 2036. The plan is to fund 300,000 new homes.

Even if the group doesn’t secure funding, many of its customers – including Registered Providers and Local Authorities – are likely to succeed. These partnerships accounted for 74% of completions in 2025.

Despite its recent woes, I think Vistry’s worth a closer look. It retains a strong balance sheet and has an order book worth £4.5bn. And despite tough market conditions, it managed to increase its average selling price in 2025.

But it might take a while before things start to improve so the stock’s likely to appeal only to patient investors. I’m confident that the group will be successful in bidding for SAHP cash – nobody in this sector of the market comes close to matching Vistry’s size and scale. But with planning bureaucracy and all the other red tape associated with government contracts, I suspect it will be a few years before these properties are built.

However, on balance, I think the stock’s one for long-term investors to consider.

The post Down 67% with a P/E of 7.8. Is this a once-in-a-decade chance to buy this downtrodden FTSE 250 stock? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

The main issue seems to be margin contraction as the company cuts prices to shift volumes in a challenging market. But I think that misses the bigger picture when it comes to this company.

What’s the problem?

Vistry’s outlook for the first half of 2026 isn’t particularly positive. The company has excess inventory that it’s looking to shift via discounts and it’s focusing on bringing down its debt.

Neither of these is a particularly positive sign. While lower prices have generated some strong sales growth in the company’s open market division, they’re also likely to cut into profit margins. 

Vistry’s open market sales are less than 33% of the firm’s total revenues. But they account for a greater share of the profits and that’s why margin contraction is such a concern for the firm.

Reducing debt isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but a closer look at the results reveals it’s coming at the expense of share buybacks. And these could have been a significant return for shareholders.

Vistry spent around £130m on buybacks in 2025 and with the stock down, that’s 10% of the total market value. But investors will have to wait in 2026 as the focus shifts to strengthening the balance sheet.

That’s why the share price has crashed. But while neither of these is a welcome development, my reason for owning the stock remains firmly intact.

The bigger picture

Vistry’s partnership division is what sets it apart from other builders. It builds for housing associations, local authorities, and private landlords, who then buy the properties. 

This means the company can build more houses with less of its own money and has more predictable sales. And right now, there’s another huge advantage to this approach.

There’s £39bn in government funding for affordable homes between now and 2036. Vistry’s established relationships give it a huge advantage as a partner – and the competition knows it.

Nothing in the latest report changes this. And the company expects strong demand in the second half of the year in its partnership business as the bidding process gets going. 

A 20% drop takes the stock to a five-year low, but what I see as the main reason for owning Vistry shares is still firmly intact. So that means I have an opportunity.

I’m looking to add to my investment in a big way. I can see why the stock is down and there are challenges at the moment, but the company looks fundamentally undervalued to me at £1.3bn.

Who needs a stock market crash?

A stock market crash that sends share prices down can be a huge opportunity for investors. But Vistry’s latest move means I don’t think I need to wait around for one of those. 

The stock is 20% cheaper than it was yesterday and my long-term thesis is still intact. So it doesn’t really matter to me whether or not other shares are falling – I’m buying this one.

The post Vistry shares down 20%! Here’s what I’m doing… appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.