Not all UK shares have had a happy 2026. While the FTSE 100 has been pushing near all-time highs, homebuilder Vistry (LSE:VTY) and media group Future (LSE:FUTR) have been heading sharply in the opposite direction, falling 60.9% and 39.8% respectively since January.
Beaten-down stocks can make for compelling buying opportunities. But they can also be falling knives. So which is it here?
Vistry: a business in genuine distress
Vistry’s implosion began in October 2024 when the group revealed a £115m cost underestimation in its Southern division. It was a bombshell discovery that shattered investor confidence in management’s numbers. The share price has so far never recovered, and 2026 has only brought fresh pain.
The most recent trading update confirmed that first-half profits will be “significantly lower than the prior year”.
The reason? A glut of completed Open Market homes that management is being forced to sell at heavy discounts to shift inventory and raise cash. The share buyback has been paused, and the focus is now squarely on debt reduction.
The business isn’t entirely without merit. The forward order book stands at £4.5bn, the government’s 1.5 million homes target provides a structural tailwind, and management expects the second half to recover as partner revenues from the new Social Affordable Housing Programme accelerate.
At the same time, a new CEO, Adam Daniels, is conducting an operational review with findings due at the September interim results. And while this may reveal more skeletons lurking in the closet, it could also potentially be the key turning point that investors have been waiting for.
The bear case however, is hard to dismiss. Analysts are projecting adjusted pre-tax profits to land between £168m and £283m. That’s a massive gap and reflects just how uncertain the profit profile looks, especially now with the unknown impact of expected inflation from the conflict in the Middle East.
Future: disruption with no clear resolution date
Future’s share price has been dragged down by a structural problem: the business remains significantly reliant on Google search traffic to drive programmatic advertising and eCommerce affiliate revenue, both of which are currently being disrupted by AI.
In the first half of 2026, revenue fell 8% and adjusted EBITDA dropped 24%, with eCommerce affiliate revenue down a painful 24% organically. At the same time, reported pre-tax profits collapsed from £56.6m to just £18.4m.
To be fair, management isn’t standing still. Its AI visibility product Future Optic has already booked £10m for the full year, and its Google-zero strategy of building direct audience relationships through newsletters, events, and subscriptions is making early progress.
But with £314m in net debt, leverage on the rise, and revenue still declining across most divisions, the path to recovery requires multiple things going right simultaneously.
So what’s the verdict?
Both businesses have real qualities and genuine recovery potential. But both also carry risks that aren’t fully resolved yet. And in all honesty, it’s simply too soon to tell whether Future can adapt to an AI-first world or Vistry withstand rising costs.
That’s why, for investors seeking beaten-down UK shares with a cleaner risk-to-reward profile, there are likely more compelling opportunities to explore elsewhere right now.
Should you invest £5,000 in Future Plc right now?
When investing expert Mark Rogers and his team have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Twelfth Magpie Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets.
And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if Future Plc made the list?
Zaven Boyrazian does not hold any positions in the companies mentioned.
